Ask what they’d do first, why they’d do it, what you’ll receive and how you’ll review progress. Give each provider the same short brief so you can compare their answers against the same business problem.

Give them enough context to make a recommendation

Share what you sell, who buys it, how customers find you today and what you want to improve. Include your website or relevant profiles, what you’ve already tried, and any budget or timing constraints. A sentence such as “Most of our enquiries come from referrals, and we want more suitable enquiries through our website” gives a provider something concrete to investigate.

Ask these five questions before you agree

  • What would you check before recommending work? If your website gets visits but few enquiries, ask how they’d check who is visiting and whether the enquiry process works.
  • What will you deliver, and what will you need from me? Ask which pages, profiles or content they’ll work on, who supplies materials and who approves changes.
  • Can you show a relevant example and explain your role? Ask what problem the client had, what the provider changed and how they assessed the result.
  • How will we review progress? Agree on a review date and a measure that fits the work. If your goal is more suitable enquiries, ask how you’ll identify and count them.
  • What will I pay, and who owns the accounts? Ask for a breakdown of one-time fees, recurring fees and third-party costs. Confirm who controls the website, domain and analytics accounts and what access you’ll have when the work ends.

Compare proposals against your immediate priority

Read each proposal beside your original brief. If the priority is to fix a website that gets visits but few enquiries, look for a proposal that explains how it will investigate that issue and what it will deliver. If a proposal promises results without explaining the work or how progress will be measured, ask for those details in writing before agreeing.